Montgomery's Steak House

Write a Review765-987-8000

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 12:00pm

A great place for dinner! The food is amazing! The lamb was probably the best ive ever had! Mushrooms are to die for! And pizza king pizza is great when less formal dining is desired!

I just drove my family 122 miles round trip to treat them to a wonderful steak dinner at montgomery steak house in spiceland, in. After arriving at5:45pm on saturday , 11/8/2014 we had to wait 30 min. To be seated. (Ok) after ordering, it took 45 min. To get our meal. 3 of the steaks were ordered as medium/well but they came out cool very pink in small pools of blood. They took them back to redo and they still came back on the rare side. Not edible. My wifes baked potatoe was burnt crispy black, also not edible, and they informed us they did not have anymore. There was a 4th steak very rare and bloody but our son decided to eat it anyway. He could only eat half of it and his baked potatoe burnt on the outside so he ate half of the inside. We were given styrofoam cups because they were out of dishes. We did not get any bread or butter and no salt or pepper. The bartender came out to apoligize and took $2.50 off of our $91.00 very bad meal with extremely poor service. I am 72 years old and I can not remember a meal or dinning experince this bad in my life. We checked some tables before leaving and they did not seem to be experiencing these problems. I can not recomend them to anyone again.

I just drove my family 122 miles round trip to treat them to a wonderful steak dinner at montgomery steak house in spiceland, in. After arriving at5:45pm on saturday , 11/8/2014 we had to wait 30 min. To be seated. (Ok) after ordering, it took 45 min. To get our meal. 3 of the steaks were ordered as medium/well but they came out cool very pink in small pools of blood. They took them back to redo and they still came back on the rare side. Not edible. My wifes baked potatoe was burnt crispy black, also not edible, and they informed us they did not have anymore. There was a 4th steak very rare and bloody but our son decided to eat it anyway. He could only eat half of it and his baked potatoe burnt on the outside so he ate half of the inside. We were given styrofoam cups because they were out of dishes. We did not get any bread or butter and no salt or pepper. The bartender came out to apoligize and took $2.50 off of our $91.00 very bad meal with extremely poor service. I am 72 years old and I can not remember a meal or dinning experince this bad in my life. We checked some tables before leaving and they did not seem to be experiencing these problems. I can not recomend them to anyone again.