Johnny's New York Pizza

Write a Review954-537-7772

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

FRIENDS AND FAMILY ALWAYS BRAG ABOUT THIS PLACE.MY PARENTS HAD SAID THAT THEY HAVE BEEN UNDER NEW OWNERSHIP SINCE MAY, SO WE GAVE IT A TRY BEING THAT WE JUST MOVED DOWN FROM NY ON MONDAY... WE ORDERED A BAKED ZITI PIZZA ALONG WITH 50 WINGS AND A SPAGHETTI W/MEATBALLS.. PIZZA WAS EVEN BETTER THAN WE EATEN IN NY, SAUCE WAS LIKE MY GRANDMOTHERS GRAVY, WINGS WERE AWESOME.. TOOK ONLY 40 MINUTES FOR DELIVERY AND WE LIVE OFF OF FEDERAL AND COMMERCIAL... WE WILL BE THERE PICKINGUP THEIR $8.95 PIZZA SPECIAL THEY HAVE FROM 3-6 ... FOOD WAS OLD SCHOOL ITALIAN STYLE !!!!!

I've ordered from these guys for a long time...I have to say, this is as close to a Manhattan slice that you will get...I ordered a Margherita pizza tonight and it was THE best margherita pie I have ever had...this is MY only go-to for pizza here. Thanks, Johnny's...GREAT PIE!!!!!

I'm rarely inclined to write a bad review, but our last visit to Johnny's was a disaster. First, the positive: Waitress was nice and caring. We got $1.50 taken off our check. Pizza was good. Garlic rolls were great! We usually order the pizza as take out, but this was the first time we've eaten in. Upon being seated, we ordered a lunch specials that included salads. They were brought promptly covered in saran wrap. Strange, we thought. Anyway, waitress uncovered it at the table. We were about to take a bite when I thankfully caught something--my Husband's onions were see-through and green with mold, the lettuce was brown on the edges, and the plastic dressing bottles were filthy with encrusted dirt in the grooves that I could scrape off with my nail, and hair sticking on the bottom. It was the most unappetizing salad i've ever seen in my life. The waitress apologized sincerely and took them back. We decided to nix the salads and just wait for our meals. My pizza was tasty. My husband got Chicken Parmegean. The pasta that came with it tasted like a dirty kitchen sponge. There was just something "funny" about it. I truly hope that tonight we don't get some kind of food poisoning. I researched their last health inspection, and it wasn't the best: https://www.myfloridalicense.com/inspectionDetail.asp?InspVisitID=2930686&id=2147136 I also saw a dislayed bin with silverware that was soiled on the outside. I lost a lot of confidence in the restaurant, and I'll have to think really hard if i'll ever take out pizza from here again. Eater, please beware.