Plaza 57 Collectibles

Write a Review212-246-2000

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 9:00am

I wish i did not enter this place...the appraiser was very rude and acted sort of prejudice.... While the staff was pleasantly nice... He had me come there and didn't even view or stamps...wow!!!! He also told me i wouldn't get much for my coins...wrong!!!!
But i went some where else and got a good amount of money for my coins...thanx rude dude!!!

Just bought a watch! Omega, i love it! Great place, decent prices.

Sandra from Springfield, NJ. I had some art works that was purchased by my ex-husband a while ago. I don’t understand anything in arts and I always personally hated that pictures but just throwing them away seemed like a waste. I heard about the Plaza from the ad on a radio and decided to invite an appraiser home in order to sell the paintings. The appraiser came the next day and offered a good price for the pictures. I also had some old gold jewelry at home that I don’t wear anymore. The appraiser advised me to bring it in the store. He said I will be able to get a good deal for trading in my old jewelry for a new jewelry or watch. I’ve already made an appointment for coming in on Wednesday. Considering all the positive reviews, it should be amazing experience. I’m looking forward to it.

My name is Terry. My father turned 70 recently and I wanted to make a special gift for him. He used to have a Rolex watch that was stolen from him a year ago. I new he loved the watch a lot and couldn’t find anything to replace it. The watch was old and it was hard for me to find the same one. Likely, my friend told me that they were in Plaza recently and it was an amazing choice of antique watches there. I was able to find the watch that was very similar to the one my father used to have, except the color of the strap was different, but the salesperson told me that they will be able the replace the strap on anyone I like and also advised to make an engraving on the back of the watch. What a great idea! I picked the watch with a new strap and engraving in 2 days. The watch looked perfect. My father loved the present.

They said the have over 25000 watches!! and if you look around you believe them!! I





looked at their Omega watches. They showed me over 1000 Omega watches!! Do you







understand, over 1000 just Omega watches! I didn't there are that many in the whole









New York City! They has styles and models I never new ever existed! They were all in







perfect condition including many old ones from the 1920's. Everything they sell is





guaranteed. Their prices are quite good and they buy and take trade ins. They also have







an expert appraiser on staff. I bought and Omega and a vintage Rolex for less the







expected to pay just for the Omega!! Will definitely be back!

Awesome Selection of Watches & collectible - 30 years of experience I have never seen





so many watches in my life! They say they have over 10000 watches, I think it's over





20000!!They have all price ranges from $100.00 to over $100000.00 All are discounted





from 20% to 75% of the replacement value! They say they have been on 57th street for





over 30 years, and I have been a customer for over 10 years. Ask them to show you a





vintage Omega Seamaster, they will show you over 500 Omega's to choose from!!





Everything they sell comes with a lifetime guarantee, 2 year warrantee on parts and





labor and a free certified insurance appraisal for replacement costs. I have bought





many watches and jewelry pieces from them over the years and have always been





very satisfied. I'm from a small town in Ohio and they have more Rolex watches in





their store than ALL the jewelry stores in Ohio put together! A must see in when in





NYC! They also have huge selection of sports memorabilia and entertainment items





as well. Well worth a visit, especially from out of town!!

I was supposed to go to the concert to Carnegie Hall with my wife. Due to the fact we



arrived earlier we decided to walk around and walked into the Plaza out of the curiosity.



We were amazed by their inventory. It seemed they had everything there: watches,



baseball cards, sports memorabilia… While I was standing there staring at the spots



items my wife picked an expensive ring that she absolutely loved. I wasn't ready to



spend a lot of money but the owner gave me a great discount. I just couldn't miss this





offer. So be very careful while walking in the store with your wife, she will definitely



find something that she likes there : )))

Largest Sellection of Watches & collectible - 30 years of experience



I have never seen so many wathces in my life! They say they have over 10,000 watches, I think it's over 20,000!!They have all price ranges from $100.00 to over $100,000.00 All are discounted from 20% to 75% of the replacement value!They say they have been on 57th street for over 30 years, and I have been a customer for over 10 years. Ask them to show you a vintage Omega Seamaster, they will show you over 500 Omega's to chose from!! Everything they sell comes with a lifetime guarnatee, 2 year warantee on parts and labor and a freee certified insurance appraisal for replacement costs.I have bought many watches and jewelry pieces from them over the years and have always been very satisfied. I'm from a small town in Ohio and they have more Rolex watches in their store than ALL the jewelry stores in Ohio put together! A must see in when in NYC!



They also have huge sellection of sports memorbila and entertainment items as well. Well worth a visit, especially from out of town!!

12/19/2011



They have the largest selection of watches I have ever seen! They say they have over 20,000 watches and if you look around you will believe it.



I looked around for about 1 hour. I came back the next day and bought a Breitling and a Patek Phillipe watch. The price I figured was about half the retail price which was really fair. While I was there, the place was really busy, they were buying and selling everything! The purchased an Andy Warhol painting and a signed Babe Ruth baseball. They also sold and Abraham Lincoln letter and appraised a collection of original World Series rings! One of the other clients was saying he was there when James Bond (Daniel Craig) bought a couple of watches there a few weeks ago!!

It's really a wild place and sometimes crazy busy, but you will always get a really good deal. They also buy anything and I thing they pay very fair prices.

Overall I would state the following:



The selection is the largest in the world. The prices are excellent. The place especially when crowed is a little small. The items are not the that organized. The experts are sometimes busy, but when available will answer any questions you will have. They do go out of their way to try to make you happy.



Overall a very unique experience and recommended.

I am an avid boxing collector. I was specifically looking for Ali memorabilia and Plaza had the things I was looking for. This is great since Ali sports goods are getting harder and harder to find. I mean the original wrist tape that Ali wore in the Foreman fight is just simply amazing! Go here if you want to find some true gems.

I was recommended to go there by a watch collector friend. They have the largest selection of watches I have ever seen! They say over 25,000!!!

Anyhow, I bought a Gold Rolex for less than half the normal retail, and also bought a Rookie Mickey Mantel card for less than $15,000.00!! Both came with certificates, appraisals and guarantees. They say they have over one million cards and over 5,000 signed baseballs!!

A great place just to visit!!