Randy's Fishmarket Restaurant

Write a Review239-593-5555

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

Fresh Grouper, lightly blackened is excellent. I also liked the seafood gumbo.

Fabulous food. Excellent service.A favorite place. Always jam packed for good reasons....even in the off season.

Food was amazing. Very fresh would highly recommend it especially the sea bass. Hotel bar tender suggested it and it was great!

Horrible food--extemely overrated--We found this restaurant in an ad in the airline magazine implying that it was one of the "best seafood restaurants in the world."



We later found that this was a paid for advertisement and the restaurant was not rated by anyone. It seems that Randy bought the rating as one of the best.



I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone--there are many many seafood restaurants in Naples that are much better in terms of quality, quantity and price.



He also rates his grouper sandwich as "voted best of the best." It does not say who rated it, but I suspect that it was Randy himself. The grouper sandwich is dismal.

The most overrated restaurant in Naples. It is marketed as one of the best seafood restaurants in the US--not true--paid for advertising. Grouper sandwiches were voted "best of the best"--by whom????????????????????????????

Diner beware.

The previous reviewer obviously got them on a bad night. We've never experienced a bad night in maybe a dozen trips to Randy's. It's always top quality seafood with good service. Their NE clam chowder is truly fabulous. The wait on any in-season evening can test anyone's patience. Maybe up to an hour, but the many regulars attest to its great food. They also feature a grocery section with fresh seafood to prepare at home.

We were referred here by a friend. We thought we would check it out, before bringing the kids and grandkids. Good thing, the food was served to us cold and the sea bass was slimy. We tried to tell our waitress, but she never returned to our table, we then asked for a manager and we were told our waitress was the manager. The hostess finally sent our waitress back to our table and we told her our food was cold, she reached down and touched it and said it seemed fine to her. Please stay away from this place.