Peters Market

Write a Review845-647-6990

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 8:00am

Jeremy Peters, the proprietor, refused to refund my $75 for two putrid filet mignon sleeves just recently purchased from his meat bin; although his butcher had taken them back from me in Peters absence, telling me to return when the boss was in for my money, & explained how bacteria sometimes infects meat prior to kryopacking, etc. So I sued them in the Court of Small Claims in Ellenville & needless to say they won; with a wink & a nod from the sitting judge to the senior Peters. Their lanky lawyer seemed to have stepped right out of the iconic Hank Ketcham cartoon, he was the living image of Dennis' father. But hardly the Catskill Clarence Darrow. However, for only $25 I had had my day in court; all alone with my humble but forthright Anglo-Saxon screed against their 'lanky' lawyer's Latinate legalisms; my loss was a well-fought defeat, but that sickeningly sweet, septum-searing scent from the Peters Market meat is still with me. Almost incarnate, if you will.

What once was a great meat dept. is now awful.

They do not have what used to be known as a "Butcher" the meat sometimes is green in the cooler. Several times I have had to return Chicken because it smelled. I heard a man saying they repackaged the meat ,updated the date. That's not good. Other then the meat dept. the rest of the store is very nice. The workers are wonderful! BUT, Parking lot is a nightmare.

Peter's Market is an excellent small grocery store. it has a wide assortment of natural products, the best in our area. it has short waits on the cashier lines and all the stores merchandise is top quality. they carry shurfine products as their "store brand" items. the best part of the shopping experience for me is the customer service; the friendliness, helpfulness and courteousness of the staff at the store. I would rate this store A+