Website IconWebsite
Pagliai's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, in Murray, KY, is the premier pizza restaurant serving Cadiz, Paducah, Benton, Hardin, Paris and surrounding areas since 1972. We specialize in authentic cuisine made using family recipes from Italy. We use only real ingredients, nothing artificial. For your next meal, visit Pagliai's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Murray.
Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate

Reviews

JW
Jessica W.

10/05/2016

Provided by YP.com

Kids and I stopped in for lunch. Ordered the buffet expecting a decent variety. The lunch buffet consisted of 3 types of pizza, some watery spaghetti, a salad bar, and some Chips A hoy cookies on a tray. Everything on the salad bar was brown or had black spots on it. I actually tried some cottage cheese which had definitely gone bad, tasted sour. Pizza was definitely not good, but edible. Only positive was the staff was very pleasant. Kids and I ate a slice of pizza each and paid our $25 bill and left with no intention of returning ever again. Definitely disappointed. I could have gone to any other joint in Murray and gotten better food for A LOT cheaper.

L
lil_smitty293

08/07/2011

Provided by YPmobile
Not worth the money

They used to b a good place to eat but not any more.the only way you get fresh food is order it.the buffet never has fresh food and if you ask them to put something out on it they never do.I don't recommend

P
pattiepicc

05/05/2011

Provided by YP.com
Food was to nasty to eat! Wait...

Food was to nasty to eat! Waitress added her own tip to our bill after we refused to pay for food we did not eat. Made nasty comments to others about how we did not know good food when we ate it! As someone who has been in the restaurant business for over 35 years I know if something has been cooked properly and this food would make a dog sick!



See my full review in Zagat's

More Business Info

BBB Rating
A+
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.
Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Sun:
Services/Products
  • Wedding Receptions, Online Ordering with Murray Eats, Family and Locally Owned
  • Video Arcade, Indoor Play Park, Kid Friendly, Employment Opportunities, Birthday Parties
  • Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Homemade, Private Parties, Student Discounts, Delivery
  • Takeout, Drive -Thru Service, Seat over 300, Corporate Events, Large Dining Area, Award Winning
  • Special Orders, Affordable Prices, Daily and Lunch Specials, Kids Menu, Healthy Options
  • Rice Gluten-Free Crusts - 6" and 8", Cauliflower Crust - 11", Lunch and Daily Specials
  • Naan Bread - Specialty Flat Bread
  • Fresh Squeezed Lemonade. 16 oz, 24 oz, 32 oz, 44 oz
  • Buffet, Side Dishes, Lasagna, Spaghetti, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
  • Dessert, Catering, Kids Menu, Plant Based Beef, 6" and 8"
  • Pizza, Thick Vegetable Soup, Fresh Homemade Chili, Flat and Indian Bread
  • Wraps, Salad Bar, Pasta, Sandwiches, Coke and Pepsi Products
Brands
Pepsi, Coke
Payment method
visa, mastercard, amex, discover, cash, check, android pay, apple pay, all major credit cards
Price Range
$
Location
Across from Chestnut Park
Amenities
Murray's Favorite Pizza, Delicious House-Made Ranch Dressing,Authentic Cuisine Made Using Family Recipes from Italy,We Use Only Real Ingredients, Nothing Artificial
Languages
English, Spanish
Associations
Chamber of Commerce,Rotary Club
Other Links

Primary Website

Facebook

Categories
Pizza, Banquet Halls & Reception Facilities, Buffet Restaurants, Caterers, Delivery Service, Dessert Restaurants, Family Style Restaurants, Health Food Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Pasta, Restaurants, Sandwich Shops, Take Out Restaurants, Video Games Arcades
Other Information

Cuisines: Buffets, Caterers, Family Style, Sandwiches, Take Out, Italian, Dessert, European, Healthy, Continental, Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Alcohol: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Attire: Casual

Takes Reservations: Yes

Outdoor Seating: No

Price Range : Below Average

Suggest an Edit