New Bethel Ordinary

Write a Review317-862-5020

OPEN NOW - Closes at 9:30pm

heard about the pizza hear forever. So i finally got over to try it yesterday.Ordered a 16in pie loaded up. Price was about 23 dollars, had breadsticks as well 5 bucks for 6 and cold pizza dipping sauce. Bread sticks were average. So the pizza comes out, and i will admit it was loaded with toppings as it should be for 23 bucks. But the problem was the quality of the toppings, the sausage and bacon tasted cheap, pepperoni was ok. The worst part was the tomato sauce it tasted like cheap tomato paste out of a can and to finish the crust was soggy and tasted cheap as well. It's a heavy pizza and filling, but taste sucked, and was filled of cheap ingredients.Place it way overpriced. Stay away. You are better sitting at home and ordering up 2 large papa johns for the same price.

Great Pizza. They have lots of toppings and it really fills you up. We got carry out and brought it back home this time so the kids could play with their cousins. My brother's family really liked the pizza and wings. They said it was well worth the trip from Anderson to our house for the "Ordinary" food.

The best and most fullfilling breakfast for the buck. I love the refill to go when done

Very tasty pizza with large toppings. More of a mans pizza. Not alot of crust, but still quite tasty! Venue is small and smells funny, but worth it for the food. The food rocks. Bartender was somewhat attractive. :)

This place is a great "hole in the wall" that seems to be popular with locals. The pizza weighed every bit of 5 lbs. I don't know how they make one that big without losing money. Great value. I also stopped in for breakfast, also awesome. Beer specials help compliment the pizza for dinners too! I will definitely make this a frequent stop.