Indy Card Exchange

Write a Review317-254-8681

OPEN NOW - Closes at 6:00pm

Andy, the owner was very accommodating, helpful and knowledgeable. He gave us advice and took time to answer questions even when he was super busy. When I had further questions he was quick to respond with a phone call or message.
It was amazing to me that even though he didn't profit from my situation he was still willing to give me the guidance I needed!
His employees were helpful and super nice. I highly recommend his business!

Indy Card Exchange is beyond elite in every way. Of course, they have everything you could need as a longtime hobbiest or if you are just casually starting out with sports cards. Always have the new releases, hobby boxes, megas, blasters, awesome selection of vintage boxes as well, in great condition. What I love most about Indy Card Exchange is the culture and environment. All are welcome. This is not a place where longtime card collectors and their egos run the place. This is a place where it is all about the love for cards. No matter your age or experience. The guys who run the shop are awesome human beings. They have such a great kids program with monthly giveaways, incentives, etc. to help the next generation get into the hobby. This shop has refueled by passion for card collecting and everytime I walk in I have the nostalgic feeling of what card collecting is all about.

My son and I visited for the first time today. Andy and family were so polite and helpful. My son was so excited. Great prices and large selection of all types of cards. We cant wait to go back!

Indy Card Exchange, don’t even know where to begin... Andy (owner) is absolutely a hands on and knowledgeable card shop owner, but even a greater person! They treat everyone special every time. They never cease to amaze us how valuable they make every visit! Thanks for being the best in the business!

-William & Ronda Davis (Pendleton, In)

Extremely knowledgeable and friendly. Great selection. Love going into this shop.