Guilford Coin Exchange

Write a Review203-453-9363

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 9:30am

Honest and decent people, friendly and engaging.
Over the 12 years, whether we were buying or selling ,
I can say they have been consistently forthright .

Steven is an honest person!!! Also, the other person who works there is also reliable. A friend of mine recommended this place. I am glad he did.

They will pay more than the pawn shops and most other dealers IMO. You will lose money however if you don't do your research before selling. Strange that they hold out for retail or more in their shop but it looks like they are selling at wholesale on ebay. Lottery shop too? What is this another gambling outfit?

Dealer sells as "father-time-coin " on ebay. I would only want to buy certified coins, etc. from them, as many of their uncertified ones are improperly graded by them and therefore rip-offs. They don't pay fair on a number of the items sold to them, either the grouchy old guy does scathing critical analysis and pricing or one of the others makes the lowball offers. Sometimes they offer a fraction of fair market value. Check around, go online to the major buyers and sellers so you don't get ripped off!

This is one of my favorite stores to visit because their knowledge and collection of coins and other collectibles is outstanding. The people are friendly and the owner is extremely nice and gracious. I bring old coins and other things down there all the time for him to look at. For advice and information on coins, there is really no better place to visit.



Also, if looking to purchase old coins (I have a penny collection), this is the place to go. They no longer really deal in wheat cents but I used to get all the old wheat cents there and they still have a vast collection of cool collectible coins. One time I brought an old Brazilian coin down there and they looked it up in a reference book and gave me $270 dollars. They always pay legitiment prices. Great store.