Mario's Pizza and Italian Restaurant

Write a Review609-884-0085

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

Mario's has the best pizzeria pizza and Italian food. Service is pleasant and quick and they also deliver if you're hanging by the pool with friends. They know what a garlic knot is (attn other pizzerias: not zeppoli or doughy breadball) and bake em delicious. Stromboli, panini, etc. All good. The pizza is best reheated and crisped up for a brick oven touch. Nonna used to work here a lot to keep an eye on things. Its slightly less consistent now. The last veggie stromboli was overstuffed and soggy. Maybe just a fluke because its still the best in Cape May. Near the Cape May Acme so parking is easy as long as its not influx renter Saturday.

Best garlic knots! Nonnas foccacia is fantastic! Everything is fresh and delicious. We have been known to travel from Toms River just to go to Mario's!